The first half of this book
surprised me because of all of the dark problems that it covers.From
homelessness to theft, it brings up topics that are not often the main focus of
a children’s book and definitely not issues that feel so real. My heart was
already sad halfway through the first page. Georgina says, “I guess I’m pretty
good at pretending.” Her father walks
out on the family and Georgina, her mother, and brother are forced to move out
of their apartment and sleep in their car. I love how honest the book is and
how you can feel Georgina’s emotions. Her embarrassment shines through the
first few chapters and it’s fully apparent when Luanne finds out about Georgina’s
family living in a car: “If there was ever a time when I wished the earth would
open up and swallow me whole, it was when I turned around and saw Luanne
looking at me and that car and all.” The book revolves around Georgina’s
entertaining antics geared towards stealing a dog, receiving a reward after
returning it, and helping her mom get enough money for an apartment or house.
Throughout the first eleven chapters,
my mind was focused on thinking about what if I had a student who was homeless?
If they came to school with constantly dirty clothes and had poor hygiene? If I
knew that their parents were struggling to get by and didn’t even have a home? What
would I do for them? What could I do? I felt almost frustrated that Georgina’s
teacher, Mr. White, never seemed to do anything to help her. On page 50, Mr.
White related how disappointed he was in her and asked why she had a bad
attitude lately. In my opinion, that is not the way to get to a child who is
struggling and you can tell that something is wrong. You need to give them love
and show them that you care, not scare them and make them not feel trusting
enough to talk to you about it. But on the other side, later in the story,
Georgina says how much she likes Mr. White because he doesn’t bring any
unnecessary attention to her situation and struggles.
The book is full of visual
descriptives that help bring the story to life. On page 4, “When I saw Luanne’s eyes
narrow and her lips squeeze together, I knew her nosiness was about to irritate
me.” You can see Luanne’s face and definitely feel Georgina’s emotions. On page
74, Willy the dog prances, yips, and jumps around. I also enjoyed how the story
revolves around the homeless family, but homelessness has not ever been the
sole backdrop. At least not yet. In my opinion, I think that the topic of
homelessness is a tricky but great one for students. Many students have no concept of what being homeless means or how it affects people that are the same age as them. There are plenty of activities and lesson ideas out there. I found a few but here's a link to a site for ideas for students in K-2. Homeslessness Facts and Lesson Ideas for K-2
So far I'm enjoying this book and am finding it heartwarming, funny, and thought provoking. I have a feeling that the second half will be just as good as the first!
So far I'm enjoying this book and am finding it heartwarming, funny, and thought provoking. I have a feeling that the second half will be just as good as the first!
I thought that is this book was so sad. I think that it will be hard for students that are homeless to read this book, but it will help other students understand that not everyone has a perfect home or family. I love the homelessness facts that you found. That is a great resource.
ReplyDeleteI'm glad that I wasn't the only one who picked up on Mr. White's insensitiveness. I mean come on man! She's obviously more "unkempt" that she was previously, her demeanor has changed, and she has a change in academic performance, OPEN YOUR EYES! It's not a bad attitude, it's more. I don't know how investigative you can be as a teacher, but I would start paying more attention, perhaps asking if she needed more time on assignments or if she would like extra help and offer sometime to Toby as well. I know we're always hearing that teachers don't have a lot of time to do anything, but if I saw a student drastically change over the course of only a few months, I would try my hardest to make the time. Thank you for that link too!
ReplyDeleteKelcie, I am so glad you brought up Mr. White and what we as future teachers could do to help students we think may be homeless! I feel like if a student is afraid or unwilling to discuss his/her poverty with an educator, but a school staff member suspects something, that they are liable (if not legally, morally) to do everything in their power to help. My first idea would be to create a safe space and interact regularly with that particular student to show my empathy and that I care, and am willing to listen. School counselors are also great resources!
ReplyDeleteMr. White frustrated me, too. He seemed to be somewhat sensitive to the situation (like when he thanked Georgina for reading her volcano report), but he also didn't do much to help her. I wonder why he didn't try harder to talk to her? Why didn't he report her case to CPS, or at least give her some material about homeless shelters and food assistance?
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing the link about homelessness lessons! I agree that we need to teach our students about issues like homelessness.